This is the penultimate Vanguard novel, pitched as the first part of a two-part finale. The back cover trumpets it as "THE END OF AN EPIC SAGA BEGINS."
You wouldn't know it by reading it, unfortunately. It reminds me of the last book of The Expanse, where the authors failed to raise the stakes in any kind of meaningful way as the series approached its climax, and indeed, where the stakes actually seem lower than usual. I guess in theory you could do something interesting with this, but it's boring and meandering.
Star Trek: Vanguard: What Judgments Come |
![]() |
|
Published: 2011 Acquired: February 2013 Read: September 2026 |
The main plot here is that Diego Reyes, formerly commanding office of Vanguard Station, has, following his court-martial, apparent death, and stint working alongside the Klingons, accepted sanctuary with the Orion pirates, and now is residing aboard the Omari-Ekon, an Orion gambling ship docked at Vanguard, which Starfleet can't go aboard because it's treated as an embassy. The Starfleet characters want Reyes to do some spying for them, and maybe want to get him off.
And for most of the book, that's basically it? It just doesn't seem important, and it progresses very slowly. Moreover, I feel like we don't get much of a sense of Reyes himself, why he might want to live this way or how he feels about his duty.
Meanwhile, there are snippets of a couple other sideplots, but the one we spend the most time on is what Ambassador Jetanien is doing on Nimbus III, the "Planet of Galactic Peace" from Star Trek V. What Judgments Come explains how the planet became the shithole we see in the film in exhaustive detail. But why? This plot doesn't plug an interesting hole in Star Trek continuity, and it's also not interesting on its own merits. I started skimming these chapters pretty aggressively.
Also it's weird and confusing when we cut from hearing about disgruntled Klingon farmers on Nimbus III to a group of totally different Klingon farmers on a different colony planet. I thought we were still on Nimbus III for far too long.
Similarly, there's a long subplot about the USS Defiant investigating something in the Taurus Reach. Again, this seems to be here to set up the original series's "The Tholian Web," which is something that did not need to be set up. Unfortunately, introducing a whole crew of new characters doesn't play to the writers' strengths, who I think are much better at evoking tv characters than creating their own. This series is already overloaded with whole crews of generic humans, between the Endeavour, the Sagittarius, and the Lovell. We did not need a fourth! Aside from the "need" to set up "The Tholian Web," I didn't see any reason this couldn't have been one of those preexisting sets of characters.
The book does seem to know it's not very interesting because the whole thing is wrapped in an ominous frame sequence, which felt to me like it was there to make sure you knew there really were stakes. I did not find this effective at all.
If we go back to who the original core cast of Vanguard was (according to the list given in the back of book one, Harbinger), I think the series overall has made some bad choices as regards them:
- Diego Reyes: Really his character arc came to an end when he stood for court-martial in Open Secrets. He was set up as a guy making ethically dubious choices, and that came to and end there. Take that away, and he's just a generic Star Trek captain.
- T'Prynn: Similarly, her character arc came to an end a while ago... if it even really existed to begin with. The book where we learn the most about her, Open Secrets, she spends unconscious. But after that, she's just kind of there, and again, she's just a generically competent Starfleet intelligence officer. Plus, the whole idea that she was in a compromising relationship with a Klingon spy just seems to have been forgotten about! Supposedly she was in love with Anna Sandjeso, but she is never mentioned by T'Prynn. Jetanien is sadder about her than T'Prynn is.
- Jetanien: He never interacts with the other characters, and has unfortunately been shunted off into the incredibly boring and pointless Nimbus III subplot I discussed above.
- Ming Xiong: In retrospect, this guy has never felt like a main character at all. A lot of time was spent in his perspective in book one, but other than that, he usually just turns up to do some science exposition. (That's his only role here.) He has no arc and not much of a personality.
- Ezekiel Fisher: Like Ming, he ultimately never feels like a main character in reality. No arc, and his main role in the series is very generic: "wise old confidant doctor." Only the story about him in Declassified has ever done something distinctive with him.
- Rana Desai: She was written out a couple books ago, though I have a guess she'll be returning in the last book as Vanguard's "new" JAG officer.
- Tim Pennington: Like many of the main characters, his arc basically came to an end in book five, when he experience an (in my opinion) totally unearned moment of self-realization. I feel like the writers don't know what to do with him: this guy is supposedly doggedly devoted to the truth, but there's like a dozen times where he gets some kind of juicy classified tidbit and doesn't write a story about it for no apparent reason. Did I really want to read a story arc about an investigative journalist who ends up kowtowing to the wishes of the military?
- Cervantes Quinn: Like Pennington, he got a totally unearned moment of self-realization in book five. This seemingly ended his arc... but then he suddenly develops a romance with Bridy Mac, which made little sense to me, and then Bridy Mac gets killed off to make him sad because that's what happens to women in stories about men. He's not in this book very much; I'm guessing we'll get a final "redemption" moment from him in the last book.
- Anna Sandesjo: Do you remember when one of the series's two queer lead characters was killed off? Well, you've got one up on her lover, then.
- Ganz: Again, I don't really know why he was counted as a main character, because mostly he's a fairly one-note antagonist. I feel like he was more interesting in the earlier books, but has kinda gotten dumber as they've continued.
These choices hamper this book, in that it doesn't have much fertile ground for interesting character work Overall, too, the series suffers from its ostensible original remit being undermined. In the first couple books, the Vanguard crew constantly had to make hard choices. Now... they just don't anymore? As I mentioned in my review of Open Secrets, those hard choices basically dry up once Reyes leaves the series. It reeks of narrative contrivance.
Continuity note: Nogura says on p. 138 he never worked with Admiral Komack and doesn't know him very well. But back in Harm's Way there was this long scene where Nogura rips into Komack. This is an error on Harm's Way's part, as it was written later even though it's set earlier.

No comments:
Post a Comment