I have a new publication out! Well, not just a single publication, but a whole special issue!
I'll expound upon the backstory below, but the new issue of Studies in the Fantastic was co-edited by me and my friend Professor Christiana Salah. The theme of the issue is "Speculative Detectives": detective stories that are also science fiction and fantasy stories. It features:- an comparison by Orin Posner of male flâneur with the female flâneuse in China Miéville's The City and the City and Marvel's Jessica Jones season one
- an essay by Darcey Lovell about "Elementary, Dear Data," the ST:TNG episode where Data plays Sherlock Holmes and battles Moriarty
- Matthew Loyd Spencer analyzing how the first Expanse novel functions as an example of neo-noir
- a discussion of untranslated Gujarati detective fiction from the late nineteenth century by Abhimanyu Acharya
- and an article by Jessica Shafer Goodfellow about Gail Carringer's "Finishing School" series, exploring how it functions as both detective and school story
I'm very proud of the quality of these essays and the breadth of approaches they take. Detective fiction and speculative fiction are two genres that (I would argue) do some things that are very similar, but the way these two projects interact is kind of understudied as far as I can tell. This is something that Christiana and I explore at length in our introduction to the issue, which tries to tease out what the projects of the two genres are and what happens when they are brought together. We use two case studies, Wilkie Collin's The Moonstone and Terry Pratchett's City Watch novels. This is the first piece of criticism I've published in several years, and I'm very proud of it, too; I think we say some interesting stuff, and it pulls together a lot of different threads in what I find interesting about literature.
All of this, plus an amazing cover by Amelia Guerrero Almonte, a former UTampa student who took my HON 240 class a few years ago. And a couple book reviews and interviews, including one by Steve Asselin, a fellow scholar of nineteenth-century sf... but whom I know because we used to post on the same Star Trek books BBSes as teenagers!
Print publication will come in a couple weeks, though it can be preordered on the UTampa Press site. Right now you can access the issue digitally on Project MUSE if your institution has a subscription.
The issue came about because Christiana began pestering me to co-edit an edited collection with her, I think because a couple grad school friends of ours had done the same. I was into the idea in a general sense—Christiana and I have overlapping scholarly interests and approaches, and I know her to be a very diligent careful editor. But I was opposed to this in a specific sense, because I have been trying to not take on scholarly work that is not finishing up my book, so that I can prioritize finishing the book. (I have been successful in not doing other scholarly work... but this hasn't resulted in me actually finishing it, so probably it was a bad idea.)
Eventually, though, I had the idea that we should do a special issue of Studies, the journal where I already serve as assistant editor. My theory here was that it would somewhat overlap with work I already do and thus not be so much extra work.
SJ, the editor of Studies, agreed with the general idea of us doing a special issue, so then Christiana and I had to sit down and figure out what about. It would need to be something that incorporated 1) her research interests, 2) my research interests, and 3) the journal's area of coverage. It took a bit of spitballing as I recall (this was over two years ago now!), but eventually we came up with the idea of "speculative detectives," as we both are interested in detective fiction (she has published on it; I never have, but it has that epistemological hook that I really like) and it would also fit under the umbrella of the journal.
I would say we had two big inspirations. One is the work of Pamela Bedore, a professor of ours in grad school. Pam works on speculative fiction and detective fiction, and it was Pam who introduced to the two of us the idea that you can classify genres in terms of "feature" and "project," an idea I use a lot in my teaching. This is to say, you can say something is science fiction because it has a spaceship in it (a feature) or because it is about an alien world still bounded by rational rules (a project). She gets this idea from Carolyn Miller, but has a very nice discussion of it in her introduction to her recent Routledge Introduction to Canadian Crime Fiction. Our other inspiration was a blog post I wrote about Pratchett's Jingo, my favorite City Watch novel, where I used this feature/project idea to explore what happens when you mash up the heroic fantasy novel about warfare with the police procedural. These are genres with very different ideas about violence: in heroic fantasy, violence is authorized by the existence of an external morality and your heroic destiny, while in police procedurals, only the state can commit violence. So what happens when someone tries to enact a fantasy war and the police get involved?
We wrote up a CFP and sent it to SJ, who ran it by the Studies editorial board (I recused myself, of course) and it was accepted. So then we posted an open call, and also solicited proposals from some specific scholars... including Pam, though she, alas, turned us down.
From there, we had to winnow the proposals down to a set where we asked for full manuscripts. Looking back at my notes, it looks like we received 33 proposals, of which we accepted ten. SJ's advice was to accept a lot, because you don't know 1) who will come through with a completed essay, and then 2) who will survive peer review. This was good advice, because as you can see above, after going through both of those processes, we ultimately ended up with five completed essays. (We also toyed with one or both of us submitting essays, but in the end restricted ourselves to just doing an intro... though the intro came out quite long!)
I don't know how the process works at other journals, but at Studies, the special issue editors do an initial editorial pass. This is supposed to be pretty in-depth, and thus takes the place of one blind peer review, so the essays get a single outside reviewer apiece. While the journal editorial staff manages that process, the special issue editors recommend the peer reviewers. (Thanks, then, to Cari Hovanec, who as interim editor for 2025/26 managed this process but got no credit on completed issue because she was out of the position by then!)
The other thing we got to do is help select the cover art. Like most academic journals, Studies has very little budget and thus cannot pay for cover art, so we tend to need to go to people who can and will do it for free. (Studies issues tend to have cool covers.) I asked one of my colleagues who was the faculty advisor of the student literary journal if he could recommend someone who did art for it; he was like, "Why don't you just look at it yourself?" So I did, and found some cool images, in particular ones featuring eyes... and then when I looked up the artist of those, it turned out to be a former student of mine, Amelia. So I reached out to Amelia, who agreed to do the cover.... which I think came out very cool!
This post is getting quite long, so I'll stop here, and save my thoughts on writing the intro for a future post, probably when the print version comes out.



















