I have spoken in the past about how Lois McMaster Bujold has a habit of returning later to an earlier Vorkosigan book and revisiting its ideas in a deeper, often more serious, way. The Warrior's Apprentice (1986) spawned The Vor Game (1990); Shards of Honor (1986) spawned Barrayar (1991); and Brothers in Arms (1989) spawned Mirror Dance (1994).
The last of those was one of the most effective of those pairs. Brothers in Arms was a good book with some great moments, but overall treated its basic idea kind of lightly. Its fundamental concept was that Miles, overburdened with identities and obligations, meets his clone-brother, Mark, who has no identities or obligations to call his own. Was that really the escape Miles thought it would be? But Brothers in Arms keeps the big questions in the background for the most part, and the foreground is farce, intrigue, and action. So I was very thankful when Bujold returned to the concepts and ideas of Brothers in Arms in Mirror Dance, and wrote what was my favorite Vorkosigan novel thus far.
Memory by Lois McMaster Bujold |
![]() |
|
Published: 1996 Acquired: August 2026 Read: September 2026 |
Based on the format of the series thus far, where basically every Cordelia/Miles novel has fallen into such a pattern (only Cetaganda defies it), I had expected the existence of Mirror Dance before I got to it. What I did not expect was that Brothers in Arms would essentially participate in two such pairs, each with a different noves. For as much as Mirror Dance returns to the ideas and concepts of Brothers in Arms from the perspective of Mark, Memory does the same thing for Miles. Mirror Dance gave us someone with no identity or obligations, and asks us to consider what they might do in the world. Quite cleverly, Memory does the same thing to Miles.
(Like most of my Vorkosigan reviews, there are spoilers a-plenty, so stop here if that matters to you. It's a thirty-year-old book, I don't feel too bad.)
At the beginning of the novel, Miles finally screws up. Even dying wasn't as big a screwup as what he does here, which is almost kill someone he was supposed to protect, and then falsify the report. It's all devastatingly in character. The beginning of the novel is kind of slow, as Bujold is clearly moving all the pieces into position, as well as providing necessary exposition: we need to be told what Auditors are, we need to be reminded about Illyan's memory chip (I had forgotten it, so I was thankful for this), we need to be reminded about the events of "The Mountains of Mourning." But then, finally, Illyan discovers Miles's falsified report and fires him.
It's quite an emotionally intense book: this is my eleventh book in the saga, my seventh focused on Miles himself. You know how much serving in the Barrayaran military and how much the Dendarii mercenaries mean to Miles, so when he loses both you really feel it. The exploration of Miles's depression is really well done; Ivan proves himself Miles's best friend in his own inimitable fashion. I very much enjoyed the return to the events of "The Mountains of Mourning." (Once again, I pity anyone who skipped Borders of Infinity because they thought the short stories weren't important to the saga.) But it doesn't just end with Miles: then Galeni loses it, and then Illyan gets sick. God, I was on edge, I was nervous. But I was flying through the book, Bujold was cooking.
Of course, it all pays off in marvelous ways. Loved it when Miles made himself Auditor, cackled when Miles arrested the villain behind it all.
It's not just about plot, though, and that's what makes it work so well. In my review of Mirror Dance, I wrote, "Miles is a person with so many obligations weighing him down, so what would it be like for there to be a version of Miles with seemingly no obligations at all?" Mirror Dance gave us this in the form of Mark... but Memory gives us this in the form of Miles himself. He is no longer Admiral Naismith. He is no longer Lieutenant Vorkosigan. He is no longer a lover to Elli Quinn. Cleverly, he is not even a brother or a child, because Mark and Miles's parents are off-planet for most of the book. He's just Miles, stripped bare.
Thankfully, there is a Miles there; despite temptation (another genuinely nerve-wracking scene!), Miles discovers who he is when he has nothing. Apparently Bujold wrote this one after she got divorced and had to reinvent her identity. I wouldn't have thought of it as a novel about divorce, but it makes perfect sense. It works for any disruptive experience of identity and self, really: life is a constant stream of finding out we aren't who we thought we were. What do we do? We keep going on, and we find our lives anew. This is the end of the first phase of the Vorkosigan saga; I did know that at some point Miles would totally change tack, and I was worried I wouldn't enjoy it. But it's the beginning of the second phase, and I am sure I will continue to enjoy it immensely. We screw up sometimes, but all we can do is build something new out of it.
Also, as always, delightful jokes. I particularly love Ivan here.
"Are you an innocent bystander, Ivan?"
"I try to be."
Every five months I read a book in the Vorkosigan saga. Next up in sequence: Miles in Love



















