24 May 2021

Review: The Man with the Golden Gun by Ian Fleming

Originally published: 1965
Acquired: December 2020
Read: January 2021

The Man with the Golden Gun by Ian Fleming

This is the last James Bond novel; if I had known it would pick up right from the end of You Only Live Twice, I would have made sure to read it in that order, but oh well.

This isn't Fleming's best work; indeed, having now finished all the novels, I feel pretty certain that he peaked with On Her Majesty's Secret Service, and he should have just stopped there. It would have been a much better final Bond adventure than what came next. Man with the Golden Gun opens okay, with Bond-- after the events of YOLT-- having been brainwashed by the Soviets. But once he's been deprogrammed, he's sent on a mission to Jamaica to kill a thug, which feels way beneath his talents. I think another writer could really do something with this: Bond having to prove to other and himself that he's still the man who he used to be. But Fleming doesn't do that, and this is Just Another Bond Mission.

Fleming always does pretty well with the mechanics of it all: Bond playing detective is good, and Scaramanga is a good villain, and the final action sequence is excellent, and the last line is a sad summation of Bond's character. But the novel has a fatal flaw, which is that Bond could just kill Scaramanga outright early on, and his reason for not doing so is completely unconvincing. Honestly, if Fleming hadn't pointed it out, I might not have noticed it, but he lampshades it, and everything that follows from there is undermined as a result.

I read a James Bond book every four months. Next up in sequence: Quantum of Solace

Book Rankings (So Far):

  1. Casino Royale
  2. On Her Majesty's Secret Service
  3. Dr No
  4. Thunderball
  5. Moonraker
  6. For Your Eyes Only
  7. From Russia with Love
  8. The Spy Who Loved Me
  9. Octopussy & The Living Daylights
  10. The Man with the Golden Gun 
  11. You Only Live Twice
  12. Live and Let Die
  13. Goldfinger
  14. Diamonds are Forever

No comments:

Post a Comment